Commentary for Monday, April 20, 2015 – Gold closed down $9.40 on the Comex today at $1193.50 – once again dipping under $1200.00. The dollar was stronger – the Dollar Index today – ranged from 97.33 to 98.07 and is 97.97 as of this writing. However, the Dollar Index for the week was trending lower so if this is a reversal in that pattern it will chill gold on the shorter term.
The DOW was also strong today which rarely helps gold – it moved nicely above the 18,000 mark, up more than 200 points on solid earnings and the Chinese stimulus. Things a little slow in China? No problem they just lower the reserve requirements for the largest banks. When China tinkers with its monetary system it reinforces the rumors that they (and the world) fear a larger economic slowdown.
This “trouble in China” – empty commercial building syndrome has been around for years and does have a temporary cooling effect on the price of gold because they are big buyers. But in every case these fears have been thrown out the window as this manufacturing giant continues to reorder the way the world works.
Our friend Greece has said in the past that as of April 2 nd their cash reserve will be caput.
And I don’t believe there has been any general agreement as to additional financing up to this point. And remember it’s not just Greece who needs a new credit card – other EU countries like Portugal, Ireland and Spain are in a similar spot.
This information under any other circumstances would have pushed gold higher by $50.00 and created international buzz – today it created another big yawn with gold paper traders. And there is certainly no buzz across our counter so gold may be tired – cheap but tired.
Silver closed down $0.34 at $15.88. We are once again entering the “cheap zone” for silver bullion so while today’s action continues lazy it will soon heat up. This might be interesting for silver buffs – did you know it takes 3 million ounces of silver to produce enough solar panels to generate 1 gigawatt of electricity? And the Chinese claim they will create 20 gigawatts this year.
Platinum closed down $18.00 at $1148.00 and palladium was down $10.00 at $772.00. Physical supplies of platinum bullion are coming back to life at the same time action is slowing down. Still when platinum is trading $45.00 less than gold the bargain hunters begin to either add to their platinum position or trade gold bullion for platinum bullion.
Always worth reading – this from Jim Rickards (The Daily Reckoning) – Gold is (Once Again) Money – Jim Rickards has published a third book entitled “The Big Drop: How to Grow Your Wealth During the Coming Collapse.” It’s available exclusively for readers of his monthly investment letter called Strategic Intelligence.
“I only know of two men who really understand the true value of gold — an obscure clerk in the basement vault of the Banque de Paris and one of the directors of the Bank of England. Unfortunately, they disagree.” – Lord Nathan Rothschild
“Money is gold, and nothing else.” ( J.P. Morgan) – “Nobody really understands gold prices, and I don’t pretend to understand them either.” ( Ben Bernanke)
“These quotes illustrate the perennial challenge that investors face in deciding what role gold should play in their portfolios. Few understand how to value gold, and even fewer understand that gold is not really an investment – it is money. Of course, if you want a portfolio that preserves wealth, money is a good place to start.
Saying gold is not an investment may seem strange, especially since I recommend some gold in an investor’s portfolio. To illustrate this point, you can reach into your purse or wallet and pull out a dollar bill. You think of the dollar as “money,” but you do not think of it as an investment.
An investment has some element of risk, and typically has some yield in the form of interest, dividends or rent. Money can be turned into an investment by using it to buy stocks, bonds or real estate. But as a dollar bill, it is just money; it has no yield and will still be a dollar tomorrow or next year.
Gold is the same. It has no yield. An ounce of gold today will be an ounce of gold next year and the year after that. It will not mysteriously turn into two ounces. It will not rust or change shape or color. It is just gold. Yet it is money.
It’s true that the value of gold may change when measured in dollars. It is also true that the value of a dollar may change when measured in euros or ounces of gold. But these changes in relative value do not turn these units into investments; they just reflect supply and demand for different forms of money.
If holders of euros have a preference for dollars, the euro may fall relative to the dollar. If holders of dollars or euros have a preference for gold, then the value of gold may rise relative to both. Still, these changes reflect changing preferences for different forms of money, not a return on investment.
While gold is money, this fact is frequently ignored by investors. Gold often trades like an investment and is said to be “up” or “down” in dollar value, the same as a stock is said to be going up or down. Gold also trades like a commodity; in fact, the primary trading venue for paper contracts in gold is the Commodity Exchange, or COMEX. In that context, gold typically goes up in dollar terms during inflation and down in dollar terms during deflation, just like other commodities, including oil and copper.
That’s why the chart below is so fascinating. It compares the price of gold with the Continuous Commodity Index, an index of major commodities that has been maintained consistently since 1957. The index includes gold, copper, cotton, crude oil, natural gas and 12 other widely traded commodities.
Throughout 2014, the gold price closely tracked the commodity index, as might be expected. The price trend of both was downward, which reflected the strong deflationary trends that began to prevail last year. But in November, this correlation broke down and gold began to diverge sharply from the overall index.
That was not the only significant development in gold late last year. As this chart shows, the pace of gold shipments out of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York increased sharply in October and November. Over 90 tons of gold were shipped out of the Fed to their rightful owners abroad in those two months alone.
That was more than half the total amount of gold shipped out for the entire year. Bear in mind that prior to 2012, almost no gold had been shipped from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York since the 1970s.
It’s a mistake to read too much into short-time series of data such as the gold/CCI correlation or the gold shipments from the Fed. Every analyst knows that correlation of factors does not prove causation. But these two charts do suggest that suddenly late last year, gold stopped trading like an investment or a commodity and started behaving like what it has always been — money.
Late 2014 was a period when commodities generally declined because of deflation and currencies generally fell against the dollar as part of the currency wars. The declining currencies were also a symptom of deflation because currency devaluation is a way to import inflation from trading partners in order to stave off domestic deflation.
Only three major assets went up strongly in the past six months: U.S. dollars, Swiss francs and gold. The dollar/gold correlation was most striking because they had been inversely correlated since 2011 with the dollar getting stronger and gold getting weaker. Suddenly, gold and dollars were gaining strength together against commodities, euros, yen, yuan and most other measures of wealth.
Using our causal inference models, our tentative conclusion is that gold is behaving like money again. This could be an early warning of a breakdown in the international monetary system as a result of persistent deflation and currency wars. Investors are moving to safe havens, and dollars, gold and Swiss francs are at the top of the list.
However, our intelligence collections and inferential models suggest that something even more profound may be going on. Russian and Chinese gold acquisition programs have been going on for years; that story is well known to our readers. But those acquisitions have now passed the point that Russia and China need to have a seat at the table in any new international monetary conference.
Both countries have caught up to the U.S. in terms of the all-important gold-to-GDP ratio. Yet massive gold acquisitions by Russia and China continue. Can something else be going on? At a minimum, Russia and China are using gold to hedge the dollar value of their primary assets. In the case of China, those assets consist of $3 trillion of U.S. Treasury and other dollar-denominated debt. In the case of Russia, those assets consist of oil and natural gas, both of which are priced in dollars on world markets.
For China, the hedge is simple. If the U.S. inflates the value of the dollar, China will lose on its debt holdings but will make large gains on its gold. Converting some portion of its dollar reserves to gold is a good way for China to hedge its exposure to dollars.
For Russia, the case is more convoluted. In the short run, Saudi Arabia is suppressing the dollar value of oil, which hurts Russian receipts, since Russian oil is also priced in U.S. dollars. But this deflation has also tended to keep gold prices low in recent years.
When Russia sells oil at a low dollar price, it immediately converts the dollars to gold, also at a relatively low dollar price. When inflation returns, the dollar price of Russia’s gold will soar, thereby compensating it for the “lost dollars” or the earlier sales of oil.
What China and Russia have in common is they are both protecting themselves against dollar and oil price manipulation by converting their export sales into gold. While investors may have missed this development, other central banks have not.
The withdrawals from the Federal Reserve represent efforts by central banks in Germany, Netherlands and elsewhere to take physical possession of their gold in advance of a systemic monetary breakdown. The correlation of dollars and gold, the divergence of gold from commodities, the repatriation of gold from the Fed and continued large acquisitions of gold by China and Russia are all visible from the data.
The conclusions that gold is beginning to behave like money rather than a commodity and that Russia and China are using gold to hedge dollar exposures in oil and Treasury securities respectively are reasonable inferences using our models.
But is something else going on? Something that is not apparent in the data and for which the inference would be less certain? Could Russia and China be trying to corner the market in gold?
Leaving aside blatant government intervention such as FDR’s 1933 gold confiscation, there has not been a successful effort to corner the gold market since Jay Gould and “Big Jim” Fisk tried it in 1869. Even that corner was broken when the U.S. Treasury unexpectedly sold large quantities of gold after Fisk and Gould had been assured by insiders that the Treasury would not do so.
The Hunt brothers infamously tried to corner the silver market in 1979 and 1980. That corner was broken by a combination of scrap silver flooding the market in the form of tea sets and silverware and changes in exchange regulations that increased margin requirements and hurt the Hunts’ ability to maintain their leveraged futures positions.
A Russian corner of the gold market would not be leveraged on futures exchanges, because Russia is a cash buyer of physical gold. Russia is also immune from U.S. regulation; the U.S. has no enforcement powers in Russia. As in the cases of Gould, Fisk and the Hunt brothers, patience and stealth are needed at the beginning of a successful corner. Russia has both.
We will watch this story closely in the future and use our causal inference and inverse probability models to test the thesis. As signs emerge of a possible corner of the gold market by Russia, our readers will be among the first to know. In the meantime, investors who have not already allocated some portion of their portfolio to gold still have time to make the allocation at an attractive entry point.”
The walk-in cash trade was again average and the phones were slow today.
The GoldDealer.com Unscientific Activity Scale is a “ 3” for Monday. The CNI Activity Scale takes into consideration volume and the hedge book: (last Tuesday – 5) (last Wednesday – 2) (last Thursday – 2) (last Friday – 2). The scale (1 through 10) is a reliable way to understand our volume numbers. The Activity Scale is weighted and is not necessarily real time – meaning we could be busy and see a low number – or be slow and see a high number. This is true because of the way our computer runs what we call the “book”.
Our “activity” is better understood from a wider point of view. If the numbers are generally increasing – it would indicate things are busier – decreasing numbers over a longer period would indicate volume is moving lower.
When buying or selling you will receive an email confirmation. This includes a PDF File to confirm your invoice or purchase order and includes forms of payment and bank wire instructions. When doing business please check to see if your current email has been entered into the new system and check to see if your computer will accept our email (no spam).
We always appreciate you keeping us up to date when moving or changing your email.
We believe our four flat screens downstairs with live independent pricing (BullionDesk.com) are unique in the United States. The walk-in cash trade can see in an instant the current prices of all bullion products and a daily graph illustrates the range of the markets on any given day.
Yes – you can visit the store with cash and walk away with your product. Or you can bring product to the store and walk away with cash. We will even wire funds into your account that same day for a small service fee ($25.00) if you are in a hurry.
In addition to our freshly ground coffee we offer complimentary cold bottled water, Cokes and Snapple. We also provide fresh fruit in a transparent attempt to disguise our regular junk food habits as we sneak down the block for the best donuts in the world (Randy’s).
Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @CNI_golddealer. Sal is now in charge of our Facebook page and he is a self-proclaimed expert on gold conspiracy theory. He would be happy to respond to even the most ridiculous conspiracy assertion on our Facebook page so why not join the fun?
Thanks for reading – we appreciate your business and enjoy your evening!
Disclaimer – The content in this newsletter and on the GoldDealer.com website is provided for informational purposes only and our employees are not registered financial advisers. The precious metals and rare coin market is random and highly volatile so it may not be suitable for some individuals. We suggest before deciding on a course of action that you talk with an independent financial professional. While due care has been exercised in development and dissemination of our web site, the Almost Famous Gold Newsletter, or other promotional material, there is no guarantee of correctness so this corporation and its employees shall be held harmless in all cases. GoldDealer.com (California Numismatic Investments, Inc.) and its employees do not render legal, tax, or investment advice.